This restaurant is on a busy high street in Badajoz, located near the border between Spain and Portugal. There is a display of meat and seafood behind a counter on the left as you enter, with a quite large dining room to the right. The decor is unusual, with a display of stars perhaps reflecting the “Galaxia” name. The room could easily double as a 1970s disco with minimal adjustment.
We tried a selection of the starters. Iberico ham was enjoyable, though of course there is no real intervention from the kitchen here except to slice the ham. Similarly, a plate of Padron peppers from Galicia were pleasant, served warm (11/20). Tuna tartare lacked much in the way of seasoning but the tuna itself was fine (13/20). On side plates were bought-in bread rolls that felt stale and were remarkably hard in texture. At a pinch I think they could be used in a medieval siege weapon as a projectile to batter down some castle walls. Only someone anxious to visit their dentist urgently would have tried to bite into one.
This was the point in the meal when things started to go awry. Artichoke with shrimp sounds harmless but quite bizarrely came with a slice of warm supermarket cheese, like one of those cheap US cheeses that are used in some burgers. The cheese itself was salty and crushed any other flavour that may have been present in the squid and artichoke. The squid itself was at least not too chewy, but this was borderline inedible as a dish (8/20).
Worse was to come. Stir fried seafood with monkfish, prawn, hake, garlic and chilli and a little cured ham sounds pleasant, right? The reality was monstrous. Grotesquely overcooked fish pieces were accompanied by stiff, hard pieces of ham. If you could make it past the rubbery prawns and even more rubbery fish then there was a little pool of buttery garlic sauce at the bottom, which at least tasted of garlic. Even a hungry cat would have angrily sent this dish back (4/20).
Artichokes and tiny shrimps were better, but that is hardly much of a challenge. The shrimps were tiny and only a bit overcooked. The artichoke was not peeled very well but at least was cooked to a vaguely edible consistency (10/20). This was more than could be set for a laughably awful Spanish omelette (tortilla). If you were hoping for something like the lovely version at Nestor in San Sebastián then you would be in for a grave disappointment, as if you ordered a Ferrari from a catalogue and a Soviet era Trabbant turned up instead. The egg was undercooked and somehow contrived to be watery in texture, mixed in with what seemed to be cooked ham. This was absolutely dire (5/20).
Retinto is a breed of beef from southern Spain near Cadiz. We tried a rib cut ordered medium rare but arriving more medium. The beef itself had decent flavour but had a lot of sinewy, stringy bits to cut through. If you made it past these to a piece of steak then this was fine, and on its own might be 12/20. However, on the side was a plate of abominable potato chips that were soggy and could actually be folded in the manner of origami. Folding the potato crisps into exotic shapes would pass the time as you wait for the bill, as by then we certainly didn’t fancy exploring the culinary skills of the kitchen pastry section.
With just water (and a solitary small glass of beer) to drink the bill came to €67 (£57) per person. That is an awful lot of money for food that, the ham aside, ranged from deeply mediocre to extraordinarily awful. Spain has some very good ingredients, and it is a shame to see them squandered by the kitchen here. Incredibly, the dining room was busy on this Thursday lunchtime, and it is listed in two respectable restaurant guides. What is the level of the other restaurants in town that drive people here? I really struggle to recall a worse restaurant meal than this anywhere. I’m not saying it is the worst restaurant on earth as I have not been to every single one of the others, but it would certainly be a strong candidate based on this meal.
RestaurantCritic.eu
I can elaborate about all the following: I've lived in Spain for almost 8 years (in Valencia, but I've also travelled), and I've had some lovely meals, but Andy's review doesn't surprise me. Despite some real highlights, both for restaurants and ingredients, I don't understand the hype about Spanish food. Spain is teeming with restaurants (~3800 listed in Valencia city proper on Tripadvisor, 5400 if you increase the search area slightly), and perhaps at least 90 % of restaurants in Spain serve food like the worst of what Andy ate, although usually cheaper. Foreigners, both tourists or expats, have also often told me they were disappointed with the food ("disgusting", some called it). On Tripadvisor and Google Reviews many horrendous places score 4.5-4.8. I've talked to some Spaniards about how many Spaniards hardly care about anything, so because it doesn't matter much what they eat either, they are also content with eating dull, bland, overcooked and underseasoned food, such as the horrendous patatas bravas, ensalada valenciana, or all i pebre 2-3 times a week – food and drink is only an accompaniment to talking, talking, talking for hours and hours and hours. It's odd to me that in a country where people seem to eat and drink constantly they care so little about the quality of what they eat. A note about the tortilla: Like someone else also said, I've also heard Spaniards exclaim that a tortilla turned out perfect, because the centre was a bit runny. Egg, onion and potato, the pride of Spain. Haute cuisine! Yay!
Paul
@Ewan - tortilla definitely should be slightly underdone in the centre, and is usually served as such in Spain (in the good places anyway). It should not however look like the example in the pic.
Andreas Pesca
According to Michelin, The “revuelto Pepehillo” is a must! Maybe you go back there and try it and see if that changes your opinion about the restaurant
Sanjeev Varma
Hi Andy, thanks for taking one for the team!
Jens
I took the resto from my Bucketlist… enjoy Espania
Ewan
Trying to be as charitable as possible, in some parts of Spain that I've been to they actually prefer to tortilla to be overcooked on the outside and undercooked on the inside. Just a regional thing, I think. Never been to Extremadura so I can't say if it's the case here. I can't pretend to understand it - it's the same thing that leads them to enjoy limp fries (or potato chips, as here), the idea that if you simmer something in olive oil (or sunflower oil these days) for a while it automatically becomes better.
Nigel
4.5 stars out of 5 on Tripadvisor. Thank goodness Andy is here to save us.
Gourmet Gorro
I'm impressed you resisted using the line - "I'm not saying it is the worst restaurant in this galaxy..."
Jeffrey Merrihue
Yes but...otherwise quite enjoyable?
Robert Brown
Did they run out of bagels?